The CMO Struggle: Navigating Relationships with Ad Agencies and Internal Stakeholders

CMOs and Ad Agencies: A Relationship Fraught with Friction

The relationship between a CMO and their ad agency can be a delicate balancing act. While both parties share the common goal of promoting the brand and achieving marketing objectives, several factors can contribute to tension and misalignment.

1. Mismatched Expectations and Communication Breakdowns

One of the most common sources of friction stems from mismatched expectations and communication breakdowns. Agencies may focus on creative brilliance and award-winning campaigns, while CMOs prioritise measurable results and ROI¹. This can lead to frustration on both sides, with agencies feeling undervalued and CMOs feeling that their needs are not being met².

For example, agencies may not fully appreciate the internal dynamics and approval processes that CMOs must navigate to get campaigns greenlit². CMOs need to effectively communicate these internal challenges to their agency partners to ensure alignment and manage expectations.

2. Evolving Roles and Responsibilities

The lines between CMOs and agencies are becoming increasingly blurred³. With the rise of in-house agencies and the increasing complexity of the marketing landscape, CMOs are taking on more responsibilities that were traditionally handled by agencies. This shift can lead to confusion and tension, as agencies may feel that their expertise is being undermined while CMOs struggle to balance their expanded role with the need to maintain a strong agency partnership.

CMOs may find it more cost-effective and flexible to handle certain marketing functions in-house, particularly those that require specialised skills or deep knowledge of the brand³. However, it's crucial for CMOs to recognise the value that agencies bring, such as their creative expertise, objective perspective, and ability to provide specialised services.

3. Data and Technology Disconnects

In the age of data-driven marketing, CMOs and agencies must be aligned on data collection, analysis, and utilisation. However, this is often not the case. CMOs may have access to valuable customer data that agencies lack, while agencies may have specialised tools and technologies that CMOs are not familiar with⁴. These disconnects can hinder effective collaboration and prevent both parties from leveraging data to its full potential.

For instance, an agency might develop a campaign based on general market data, while the CMO has access to internal data that reveals specific customer preferences and behaviours. This disconnect can lead to campaigns that are not as effective as they could be.

4. Operational Challenges

Effective collaboration between CMOs and agencies requires a strong operational foundation. This includes clear processes for roster management, scope planning, scope management and reconciliation, fee negotiations, budget management, performance evaluation, KPI and scorecard management, briefing, and training⁵. When these operational components are not well-defined or effectively managed, it can lead to friction, miscommunication, and ultimately, a breakdown in the relationship.

5. Adapting to the Evolving Agency Landscape

Agencies are evolving to better serve CMOs in the digital age⁶. They are becoming more agile, data-driven, and focused on building true partnerships with their clients. CMOs need to recognise these changes and adapt their approach to agency management accordingly. This includes being open to new agency models, such as hybrid models that combine in-house and external resources, and embracing collaborative approaches that leverage the strengths of both parties.

CMOs and Internal Stakeholders: Navigating the Corporate Landscape

CMOs also face challenges in managing relationships with internal stakeholders, including the CEO, CFO, sales teams, and other departments. These relationships are crucial for securing buy-in for marketing initiatives, aligning marketing strategies with overall business goals, and fostering a collaborative work environment.

1. Conflicting Priorities and Lack of Alignment

Different departments within an organisation often have varying goals and priorities. While the CMO may prioritise brand building and customer experience, the sales team may focus solely on short-term revenue targets, and the CFO may prioritise cost-cutting measures⁷. These conflicting priorities can make it difficult for CMOs to secure budget and resources for marketing initiatives and to ensure that marketing strategies are aligned with overall business objectives.

2. Communication Barriers and Siloed Thinking

Siloed thinking and communication barriers can hinder effective collaboration between marketing and other departments. Marketing may be seen as a separate entity rather than an integral part of the business, leading to a lack of understanding and appreciation for the value that marketing brings to the organisation¹. This can make it difficult for CMOs to gain support for their initiatives and to effectively communicate the impact of marketing efforts.

3. Proving the Value of Marketing

One of the biggest challenges for CMOs is demonstrating the ROI of marketing activities and proving the value of marketing to the organisation⁸. While marketing can have a significant impact on brand awareness, customer loyalty, and revenue growth, it can be difficult to quantify these contributions in a way that resonates with stakeholders who may prioritise more tangible metrics.

4. Building Cross-Functional Collaboration

CMOs play a crucial role in building cross-functional collaboration within the organisation⁹. This includes working closely with IT, marketing, product, and customer care teams to ensure that marketing initiatives are aligned with overall business goals and that customer experiences are seamless and consistent.

5. Aligning with the CEO's Vision

CMOs need to be strong partners to the CEO, aligning their marketing strategies with the company's overall growth strategy¹⁰. This requires a deep understanding of the CEO's vision, priorities, and expectations. CMOs should proactively communicate with the CEO, providing regular updates on marketing performance and seeking feedback on strategic initiatives.

6. Navigating Internal Politics

CMOs need to be adept at navigating internal politics and building consensus for their initiatives¹¹. This includes understanding the different power dynamics within the organisation, building relationships with key influencers, and effectively communicating the value of marketing to different stakeholders.

7. The Evolving Role of the CMO in the Digital Age

The CMO role is constantly evolving in response to the digital transformation of the business landscape¹². CMOs are now expected to be digital strategists, data analysts, customer experience champions, and technology integrators. This expanded role requires CMOs to be agile, adaptable, and continuously learning. They need to stay up-to-date with the latest marketing technologies and trends, and be able to effectively leverage data and technology to drive marketing success.

Building Stronger Relationships: Strategies for Success

Despite these challenges, CMOs can take proactive steps to build stronger relationships with both ad agencies and internal stakeholders.

1. Foster Open Communication and Collaboration

Open communication and collaboration are essential for building trust and alignment. CMOs should establish clear communication channels with both agencies and internal stakeholders, ensuring that everyone is on the same page regarding expectations, goals, and progress. Regular meetings, progress reports, and feedback sessions can help to maintain open dialogue and address any issues that may arise.

2. Define Clear Roles and Responsibilities

Clearly defining roles and responsibilities is crucial for avoiding confusion and tension. CMOs should work with agencies to establish clear scopes of work, outlining the responsibilities of each party and ensuring that there is no overlap or ambiguity. Similarly, CMOs should work with internal stakeholders to clarify the role of marketing within the organisation and to ensure that marketing strategies are aligned with overall business objectives.

3. Leverage Data and Technology

Data and technology can be powerful tools for improving collaboration and demonstrating the value of marketing. CMOs should work with agencies to establish shared data platforms and analytics dashboards, ensuring that both parties have access to the information they need to make informed decisions. CMOs should also leverage data to track marketing performance and to communicate the impact of marketing efforts to internal stakeholders.

4. Build a Strong Internal Network

Building a strong internal network is crucial for CMOs to gain support for their initiatives and to foster a collaborative work environment. CMOs should proactively build relationships with key stakeholders across the organisation, including the CEO, CFO, sales teams, and other departments. By understanding the priorities and perspectives of different stakeholders, CMOs can tailor their communication and build consensus for marketing initiatives.

5. Embrace Change and Continuous Learning

The marketing landscape is constantly evolving, and CMOs must be adaptable and willing to embrace change. This includes staying up-to-date with the latest marketing technologies, trends, and best practices. CMOs should also encourage continuous learning within their teams and foster a culture of innovation and experimentation.

Summary of Challenges:

Agency Challenges:

• Mismatched expectations and communication breakdowns;
• Evolving roles and responsibilities;
• Data and technology disconnects;
• Operational challenges;
• Adapting to the evolving agency landscape;
• High turnover amongst agency teams.

‍
Internal Stakeholder Challenges

• Conflicting priorities and lack of alignment;
• Communication barriers and siloed thinking;
• Proving the value of marketing;
• Building cross-functional collaboration;
• Aligning with the CEO's vision;
• Navigating internal politics;
• Understanding the evolving role of the CMO.

‍

Conclusion

The CMO role is more complex and demanding than ever before. Navigating relationships with ad agencies and internal stakeholders can be a significant challenge. By prioritising open communication, collaboration, and data-driven decision-making, CMOs can build strong partnerships that drive marketing success and contribute to overall business growth.

To effectively manage agency relationships, CMOs should focus on building long-term partnerships based on trust and mutual understanding¹⁷. This includes being patient, embracing collaboration, and encouraging emotional storytelling in campaigns. CMOs also need to be aware of the different personality profiles of their agency counterparts and adapt their communication style accordingly¹⁸.

Internally, CMOs need to build a strong network of stakeholders and align with the CEO's vision to drive real change within the organisation¹⁹. This requires clear communication, a deep understanding of the company's values, and a shared language to describe the company and its goals²⁰.

By learning from successful CMOs and their relationships with agencies and internal stakeholders, CMOs can navigate these challenges and thrive in their increasingly complex and demanding roles²¹.

‍

---------

Sources:

1. Why CMOs and CFOs Are the Power Couple Every Business Needs - Sage Marketing, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.sagemarketing.io/blog/why-cmos-and-cfos-are-the-power-couple-every-business-needs/

2. Understanding the relationship between agency and today's CMO - FRED & FARID, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://fredfarid.medium.com/understanding-the-relationship-between-agency-and-todays-cmo-81624cac6478

3. 5 Crucial Reasons Why CMOs Take a Backseat to Digital Marketing Agencies - Chatter Buzz, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.chatterbuzzmedia.com/blog/what-does-a-marketing-agency-do/

4. Exploring the Challenges CMOs Face in Shaping Effective Strategies - My Digital CMO, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://mydigitalcmo.io/article/cmo

5. A CMO's Wake-up Call: not Who but How - Agency Mania Solutions, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://agencymania.com/a-cmos-wake-up-call/

6. How Agencies are Evolving to Better Serve CMOs | LBBOnline, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://lbbonline.com/news/how-agencies-are-evolving-to-better-serve-cmos

7. The role of the CMO in long-term brand building, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.cmoalliance.com/the-secret-to-successful-long-term-marketing-plans/

8. 5 Biggest Challenges for CMOs in 2024 [With Proof] - CODESM, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.codesm.com/blog/biggest-challenges-cmos-2024/

9. Aligning stakeholders: Why every CMO should care about online community building, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://khoros.com/blog/why-every-cmo-should-care-about-online-community-building

10. Why CMOs Should Be CEOs' Partners In Growth And Cross-Functional Leadership - Forbes, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbescommunicationscouncil/2021/07/14/why-cmos-should-be-ceos-partners-in-growth-and-cross-functional-leadership/

11. We Asked Agencies About the Biggest Challenges CMOs Face—Here's What They Said, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://salespanel.io/blog/marketing/agencies-address-challenges-of-cmos/

12. The Role of the Chief Marketing Officer (CMO) in Business Success in 2025 - Jake Jorgovan, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://jake-jorgovan.com/blog/role-of-chief-marketing-officer

13. Navigating the Digital Landscape: Unraveling the Role of the Modern CMO - Medill IMC, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://imcprofessional.medill.northwestern.edu/blog/cmo-responsibilities

14. Digital Transformation: 12 Big Ways A CMO's Role Is Evolving - Forbes, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesagencycouncil/2024/02/09/digital-transformation-12-big-ways-a-cmos-role-is-evolving/

15. The Powerful Chief Marketing Officer role: Digital Strategist, Innovator, and Change Leader, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://dataslayer.ai/blog/chief-marketing-officer-role

16. The Evolving Role of CMOs - Archway Marketing Services, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://archway.com/blog/the-evolving-role-of-cmos/

17. CMOs: How to get the best out of agencies - Hoorah Digital - Bizcommunity, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.bizcommunity.com/article/cmos-how-to-get-the-best-out-of-agencies-586540a

18. How do CMOs make decisions? And How Can The Ad Agency Help? - Sanders Consulting, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.sandersconsulting.com/cmos-make-decisions-can-ad-agency-help/

19. How CMOs Can Succeed by Balancing Influence and Control - IDX, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://www.idx.inc/blog/How-CMOs-Can-Succeed-by-Balancing-Influence-and-Control

20. How to Get Your CEO and CMO in Sync | Built In, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://builtin.com/articles/leadership-CMO-CEO-alignment

21. For Cmos And Agencies: The Secrets Of A Successful Global Marriage - R3, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://rthree.com/insights/for-cmos-and-agencies-the-secrets-of-a-successful-global-marriage/

22. Success factors for the CMO | Change Management Office - Issoria, consulté le mars 11, 2025, https://issoria-change.squarespace.com/articles/cmo-success-factors

‍